Directory of Nonprofit Executive Search Firms

August 8, 2022
Posted in Recruiting
August 8, 2022 Recruiterie

According to the National Council of Nonprofits, there are approximately 1.3 million charitable nonprofits that are registered with the Internal Revenue Service in the United States. Not only do these organizations make a positive impact on their communities, but they also stimulate economic activity and job growth.

For any nonprofit to provide these benefits to its community, it must first have the right leadership. Nevertheless, performing a search for nonprofit executive talent can be time-consuming. As a result, many nonprofit organizations turn to partnerships with some of the best nonprofit executive search firms in the nation.

There are many benefits to gain from partnering with a top nonprofit executive search firm that understands the nonprofit sector. Primarily, your partner will understand that a nonprofit search has key differences from a for-profit search. These differences include your organization’s recruiting budget and what the ideal nonprofit candidate’s philosophy should be. Nonprofit executive search firms also have access to a much larger talent pool than your organization may have on its own.


How the Executive Search Process Works

The executive search process is important for any business, but it’s especially critical for nonprofit recruiting. After all, the success of your nonprofit depends on the quality of its leadership.

A successful executive search process usually follows these steps:

  1. Determine the organization’s needs: The first step is to define what your organization needs from its new leader. This process usually begins with the development of a position description and job specifications.
  2. Conduct preliminary interviews: Once you have a clear understanding of what your organization needs, your search firm will begin screening candidates. This stage usually involves phone or video interviews.
  3. Develop a shortlist of candidates: After conducting preliminary interviews, your search firm will develop a shortlist of the most qualified candidates.
  4. Conduct in-person interviews: The next step is to bring the top candidates in for in-person interviews. This stage usually involves a panel interview with representatives from your organization.
  5. Perform reference checks: The final step is to perform reference checks on the top candidates, typically done by your search firm.

In the end, partnering with a nonprofit executive search firm is the best way to find the high-quality talent you need when you need it. To help you find the right partner for you, we’ve compiled this directory of nonprofit executive search firms from across the nation.


Table of Contents


Directory of Nonprofit Executive Search Firms by Location

National Nonprofit Executive Search Firms

This first section of our directory highlights several top nonprofit executive search firms that have national reach. By partnering with one of these firms, you’ll gain access to a national candidate network to find the perfect leader.



Recruiterie, located in Chandler, Arizona, is a national search firm specializing in nonprofit recruiting by providing customized support for nonprofit organizations. The team understands the importance of leadership connecting to the mission of the nonprofit and uses that knowledge to determine the professional and cultural fit for each role.

Recruiterie offers executive search, development search, and interim placement services to nonprofits across the nation. Using its unique 360-degree approach, Recruiterie provides consulting services to help nonprofits with their organizational development and leadership needs.

Given Recruiterie’s years of experience working with nonprofits, they know what it takes to find the right leader for your organization and understand that the process can be complex and time-consuming. That’s why they offer a variety of services to help clients through every step of the process, from start to finish.

Phone: (602) 326-6820



Scion Executive Search

Scion Executive Search is a national search firm that focuses on recruiting for foundations, educational institutions, and other nonprofit organizations.

Phone: (888) 487-8850



Isaacson, Miller

As one of the notable nonprofit executive search providers in the U.S., the Isaacson, Miller team is committed to supporting the success of their clients by recruiting top talent for nonprofit organizations.

Phone: (617) 262-6500



Atlanta, Georgia

With Atlanta’s nonprofit sector steadily growing, the city makes for a great spot to find culturally aligned talent. Consider partnering with these Atlanta nonprofit search firms to aid in your search.


BoardWalk Consulting

BoardWalk Consulting understands the impact of a great leader, so its recruiting team works to find fitting leaders for organizations throughout Georgia.

Phone: (404) 262-7392



Georgia Center for Nonprofits

The search consultants at the Georgia Center for Nonprofits use personal experience in the industry to narrow down your executive search.

Phone: (678) 916-3000



Dallas, Texas

The nonprofit sector in Dallas, Texas, continues to expand as more organizations appear each year. If you’re looking to expand your nonprofit organization, examine the services offered by these Dallas nonprofit executive search firms.


PNP Staffing Group

Founded in 1996, Professionals for Nonprofits has provided top talent to numerous nonprofit organizations throughout the Dallas-Fortworth area.

Phone: (212) 546-9091



Thomas R. Moore Executive Search

As a nonprofit recruitment development specialist, Thomas R. Moore works with nonprofits to find the best-suited candidates for any position.

Phone: (817) 548-8766



Denver, Colorado

Denver is burgeoning with qualified talent, making it an ideal place to find your next hire. Consider partnering with these Denver nonprofit executive search firms to streamline your search.


EFL Associates

As a retained executive search firm, EFL Associates works with clients to locate fitting talent for their lead organizational roles.

Phone: (720) 200-1765



Lucas Group

The Lucas Group uses a personal approach to help clients build their dream team with culturally-aligned nonprofit talent.

Phone: (800) 466-4489



Houston, Texas

The city of Houston is home to hundreds of nonprofit organizations that help stimulate the city’s economy. Take a look at these top nonprofit executive search firms in Houston to build your organization.


Murray Resources

Murray Resources has experience placing qualified candidates in a variety of leadership roles, ranging from C-level Executives to Director-level leaders.

Phone: (713) 935-0009



Spencer Stuart

Spencer Stuart draws on in-depth industry knowledge and a client’s needs to create unique executive search solutions.

Phone: (713) 225-1621



Phoenix, Arizona

As a hotspot for employment growth, Phoenix’s nonprofit sector remains a promising place to find top talent. Consider the services of these Phoenix nonprofit executive search firms to get started.



TowerHunter’s nonprofit search team has experience filling critical leadership positions such as Director roles and various C-level positions.

Phone: (602) 652-8619



Blue Signal

As one of the top nonprofit executive search firms in Phoenix, Blue Signal specializes in executive placement for industry leaders throughout the Phoenix nonprofit sector.

Phone: (866) 335-1903



San Diego, California

Along with its peaceful climate, San Diego is also known for its expanding nonprofit industry. If you’re looking for nonprofit talent in America’s Finest City, examine these San Diego nonprofit executive search firms.


Brown Thompson Executive Search

The team at Brown Thompson is dedicated to providing exceptional service through a collaborative executive search approach.

Phone: (858) 452-1200



Resource Management & Acquisitions

RMA is an executive search firm specializing in recruiting solutions for San Diego organizations, startups, nonprofits, and more.

Phone: (888) 646-2607



Seattle, Washington

When expanding your nonprofit organization in Seattle, you need the right search to find suitable talent. Assess these Seattle nonprofit executive search firms to find the partner you need.


Hagel Executive Search

Hagel Executive Search promises a transparent search with long-lasting placements that align with your stakeholder’s needs.

Phone: (253) 693-2780



Campbell & Company

Campbell & Company’s team works closely with you to aid you in recruiting passionate nonprofit leaders.

Phone: (877) 957-0000



Recruiterie’s Nonprofit Focus

Recruiterie specializes in executive searches for nonprofits. We understand the unique challenges and needs of the sector and have a proven track record of recruiting top talent. Our 360-degree approach considers the organizational culture, mission, and values to identify the best candidates.

Recruiterie’s nonprofit services include:

  • Leadership Development
  • Organizational Assessment
  • Retained Executive Search
  • Interim Placement
  • Nonprofit Consulting

If you are a nonprofit looking for a top nonprofit executive search firm, you can count on Recruiterie to deliver. We are one of the leading executive search companies specializing in nonprofits. We have a proven track record of recruiting top talent. Contact us today to learn more about our services.


Get Connected

There’s a better way to recruit; let our executive recruiters show you how.

CALL: (602) 326-6820

4980 S. Alma School Road
Suite A2 #310
Chandler, AZ 85248